Evan Conklin Blog
Evan Conklin A Queen Anne Plumber, hot water radiant expert and boiler man
Why Homowners Really Need to Know A Good Plumber
- Hits: 13596
- 0 Comments
- Subscribe to updates
- Bookmark
You don't want to go on-line and search for a plumber if you don't have to. The ads and listings you see are rigged to a great degree to show you listings that generate the most profits to the search engine.
Ads for plumbing services are approaching $100 per call. Doesn't that mean we shouldn't be hiring these companies that are paying for these ads?
Would you hire a plumber that paid somebody else hundreds of dollars to give them your name and phone number?
We all know who ultimately has to cover that expense.
A study was done recently comparing the average cost-per-call of advertising on YP.com vs. Google Ad-clicks. See it here: http://searchengineland.com/study-yp-delivers-better-value-than-google-adwords-129210
This information is both eye-opening and alarming. This scenario is not coming in the future - it is already here. The companies that sell the ads are now looking at selling advertising on a "cost per call" basis. And it isn't just Google.
Look at this:
The study says that plumbers are paying $43 per call on YP.com (online yellow pages) and $94 per call on Google Ad clicks. The cost on Google is based upon an auction for best position. The top ads are there because they were willing to pay more than the others. The $94 is the cost-per-call in the study but I believe the cost is much higher here in Seattle where the advertising has been dominated by non-plumbers willing to pay more for the top slots than any fair-priced local plumber can afford. See more about this: $30+ Google Ad clicks mean $300+ cost per call.
What is not so obvious is what this really means to the homeowner who has to find a plumber on the internet.
Fact: If you call a plumber from a Google Sponsored ad (and these are the first you see at the top of the page on a Google Search), that company paid $94 on the average to Google before they ever rang your doorbell. ($327 if they search for an air conditioning service - ??? Holy Cow!)
Fact: If a plumber shows up at your door that paid hundreds of dollars for the lead that got him there, you can be assured that that job is going to cost you plenty. Your invoice is going to reflect that lead cost and not be based upon the work performed. (No wonder there are so many complaints about plumbers price gouging).
Lets take a look at who is advertising on Google today (Seattle Aug 3, 2012):
Notice that in this example that all three paid Google ads are not plumbing companies but drain cleaning businesses that aggressively advertise as plumbers. They may or may not have licensed plumbers since Washington State allows anybody with a contractor registration to advertise plumbing services whether they have any plumbers or not.
- Aardvark Rooter advertises plumbing services. The owner is not a licensed plumber and he has no plumber employed according to L&I; records (he has no employees at all).
- Jim Dandy is a sewer rooter business that advertises plumber services. They may or may not send out a plumber but most of the personnel are drain cleaners and laborers.
- Mr. Rooter is a another rooter company that advertises as a plumber. They may or may not send out a plumber as they have many personnel hired in the franchise network.
It is interesting that, at least in this example, the top three paid ads are rooter companies. There was a day, not too long ago, when you could get any drain cleaned for $35; not anymore. Every rooter guy is now advertising as a plumber (a licensed journeyman plumber goes to school, and must have 8000 hours of certified on-the job training). Rooter guys are not plumbers.
If you knew that the advertising "plumber" at your door paid $94.00 (or $300) upfront, would you still have called him? That cost is just the "sales lead" cost. There are all the other costs like truck loan, gas, office overhead, bookkeeping etc just like any other business. (The costs the author incurs running a small plumbing business in Seattle is $97.00 bare-bones for every hour on the time card). That guy is out a couple hundred bucks just to be standing there ringing your doorbell. Do you really think that that $50 Off Plumbing Service coupon is worth the paper you printed it on?
Established local businesses typically do not spend big bucks on advertising. They don't need to traditionally. Every dollar spent on advertising requires three dollars in gross sales to break even historically. Nobody wants to work all day and then give all the profit to an advertiser.
There are three types of businesses advertising plumbing services that are willing to spend big bucks on advertising:
- Those with no name recognition, no customer base and no local history (and usually no plumber license)
- Those that need new customers every morning because nobody would ever hire them twice.
- Con men and hustlers that are willing to pay any price to get inside your home to "sell" unneeded services.
Traditional plumbers that invested years getting certified, skilled and licensed usually are not interested in the sales and marketing hustle. Traditional plumbers are under duress however and in danger of disappearing if consumers don't realize what is happening with Internet advertising. Most residential plumbing shops have abandoned charging by the hour and want to pay the "plumber" on a commission basis. A good plumber is having a hard time finding a place to work that doesn't require him to be a salesman first. If the shop pays hundreds of dollars for a customer job upfront they only want an up-selling salesman to take the call.
The real problem is that nobody knows their neighbors anymore and we are disconnected from our local community. Why do we call franchises, those impersonal corporate services at all? How is calling an 800 number, or hiring somebody that has to drive fifty miles to my house, better than calling a local business down the street? Since when is an implied cost saving in an ad better than an hourly price quote on the phone?
My advice to homeowners: Find and hire your neighborhood plumber
Find yourself a local plumber that doesn't pay for Google sponsored advertising, billboards, ads on the bus etc. A real local plumber costs less, has a plumber license, has his name on the truck usually and he isn't under such great pressure to turn every service call into a big sale. Your neighborhood plumber cares about the relationship with his customers. Do your homework and find out who the established local plumber is in your neighborhood. Put his name and phone number on the fridge. You will save money, make a friend, support a traditional craft and save yourself a lot of grief.